Problem 157 Solution

New Solution

Let's call:

w = width of river
r = rate of the boat which was 700 yards from the destination shore at the time of the first meeting
t = duration of time from start to first meeting
  1. t=(w-700)*r
  2. 3t=(2w-300)*r

    This step is the humdinger. If you draw the pathes of both ships you'll see that after the first meeting point the combined distance covered was the width of the river. At the second meeting the combined distance traveled was three times the width of the river. So, at the second meeting time, both boats traveled three times as far compared to the first meeting.
  3. Equate 3t in equations (1) and (2): 3*(w-700)*r = (2w-300)*r
  4. 3*(w-700) = (2w-300)
  5. 3w-2100 = 2w-300
  6. w=1800

Old Solution

Define the following variables:

w=width of river
s1=speed of first boat
s2=speed of second boat
t1=time until boats meet the first time
t2=time until boats meet the second time

I shall arbitrarily say that both boats are 700 yards from the shore of original of the first boat at time t1.

The following equations can be inferred from the information given:

(1) w=t1*(s1+s2)

(2) s1*t1=700

(3) w+300=s1*t2

(4) 2w-300=s2*t2

Adding equations (1) and (2) we get:

(5) 3w=t2*(s1+s2)

Substituting s1+s2=w/t1 from equation (1) we get:

3w=t2*r/t1

3w*t1=r*t2

(6) 3*t1=t2

Combining equations (3) and (6):

(7) w+300=3*s1*t1

Combining equations (2) and (7):

w+300=2100

w=1800


This problem was asked in the 'Ask Marilyn' column in the November 19, 2000, issue of Parade magazine.

Michael Shackleford, ASA - November 18, 2000